All three hold one troy ounce of silver and are backed by a national mint. The differences are in purity, security features, packaging and premium, and those matter more than the design.
If you buy one-ounce silver coins in North America, you will run into the same three names again and again: the American Silver Eagle from the U.S. Mint, the Silver Maple Leaf from the Royal Canadian Mint, and the Silver Britannia from the Royal Mint in the United Kingdom. They are government-issued legal tender, sold through dealer networks, and recognized by virtually every bullion dealer, which is what makes them easy to buy and easy to sell.
That recognition is the main reason to pay a sovereign-coin premium instead of buying generic rounds. If you are still deciding between those two categories, start with our breakdown of silver rounds vs. silver coins. This guide assumes you have chosen coins and want to know how the big three differ.
Specifications below come from the issuing mints' own product pages (U.S. Mint, Royal Canadian Mint, Royal Mint) for current-design bullion issues.
| Spec | American Silver Eagle | Silver Maple Leaf | Silver Britannia |
|---|---|---|---|
| Issuer | U.S. Mint | Royal Canadian Mint | The Royal Mint (UK) |
| Silver content | 1 troy oz | 1 troy oz | 1 troy oz |
| Fineness | .999 | .9999 | .999 |
| Face value | $1 (USD) | $5 (CAD) | £2 |
| Diameter | 40.60 mm | 38 mm | 38.61 mm |
| Key security features | 2021 redesign added security features | Radial lines, micro-engraved maple leaf privy, Bullion DNA | Latent padlock/trident image, micro-text, wave animation (since 2021) |
| Standard mint tube | 20 coins | 25 coins | 25 coins |
The U.S. Mint lists the Silver Eagle as a $1 legal tender coin containing one troy ounce of .999 fine silver, 40.60 mm across, authorized in 1986. Since 2021 the coin has carried a new reverse showing an eagle landing with an oak branch, replacing the long-running heraldic eagle; dealers often call these "Type 1" (older) and "Type 2" (current) coins.
The Silver Eagle has historically carried a higher premium than other sovereign silver coins, and that premium can widen sharply when demand spikes. Because buyers pay up to get them, Eagles also tend to command a stronger buyback than generic silver, but you should always check the actual bid when you sell. The U.S. Mint does not sell bullion coins directly to the public; you buy through dealers.
The Royal Canadian Mint lists the Silver Maple Leaf as a $5 coin of 99.99% pure silver, 38 mm in diameter, with a serrated edge. It has been issued since 1988. Its security features are a big part of its appeal:
Four-nines silver is slightly softer than .999, and Maples have a reputation among stackers for developing "milk spots," white haze that can appear over time. Milk spots do not change the silver content, but they can matter to buyers who care about appearance.
The Royal Mint lists the 1 oz Silver Britannia as a £2 coin of 999 fine silver, 38.61 mm across. Britannia silver coins struck before 2013 used the traditional .958 "Britannia silver" standard; the move to .999 brought the coin in line with other modern bullion coins. From 2021, the Royal Mint added several security features to the bullion Britannia:
In the U.S. market the Britannia is well known among dealers but slightly less familiar to casual private buyers than the Eagle or Maple. It is often priced competitively against the other two, which makes it worth checking whenever you compare.
Each coin has a slightly different "fingerprint," which makes basic checks quick once you know the numbers:
Silver is non-magnetic and highly conductive, so a strong neodymium magnet should never stick to a genuine coin and tends to slide slowly down a tilted one. That is a useful screen, not a guarantee, so combine it with weight and dimensions.
You prioritize recognition with U.S. buyers above all, you are buying for an IRA, or you plan to sell locally to individuals who know the Eagle best. Expect to pay more for that.
You want the highest purity and the strongest counterfeit protection, and you are comfortable with the possibility of milk spots on some coins.
You want modern security features from a major mint and the price per ounce is lower than the alternatives at the moment you buy.
Many stackers simply buy whichever sovereign coin has the lowest premium on the day they order. All three are liquid. Diversifying across them also hedges against any one program's premium spiking. For a wider list, including other mints and pre-1965 coinage, see our guide to the best silver coins to stack and our explainer on junk silver.
Premiums move daily. Check the per-ounce price for each coin at more than one dealer before you buy.
Compare Bullion Dealers →There is no wrong choice among these three; each is one troy ounce of silver from a major national mint. Pay for recognition (Eagle), purity and security (Maple), or modern security at a competitive price (Britannia), and let the premium on the day decide the tie.
This guide is for general information only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Product specifications, dealer policies and rules change; confirm current details with the dealer, the issuing mint or the relevant agency before you act.
Dealer premiums, shipping thresholds and inventory change. Compare the final delivered price and product availability before placing an order.
Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no added cost to you. Dealer inclusion here is not a guarantee that any one dealer has the lowest price for your order.