Advertiser Disclosure: GoldBullionReviews.com earns commissions when you click dealer links and make purchases — at no extra cost to you. Learn more →
Scams & Safety Updated November 2026

Gold and Silver Scam Red Flags: What the FTC and CFTC Warn About

Most bullion fraud follows a short list of scripts. Learn them once, using the regulators' own warnings, and you will recognize them on the first call.

Checking prices? Compare the delivered total.
Silver Gold Bull → Money Metals → Kitco → Bullion.com →
Partner links. We may earn a commission. Compare premiums, shipping, payment fees and the final checkout total; inventory and pricing change.
Updated: Read time: 7 min By: GoldBullionReviews Editorial Team

Why Gold and Silver Attract Fraud

Precious metals have three traits that scammers love. Prices are widely reported, so a salesperson can point to headlines to make a pitch sound credible. Most buyers cannot easily judge what a specific coin or bar is really worth. And payment for bullion often moves by wire or check, which is hard to claw back once it is gone.

Federal regulators have published detailed warnings on how these schemes work. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued a fraud advisory on precious metals, and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has both testified to Congress on the perils of the precious metals market and warned the public about fake government agents demanding gold bars. This guide organizes those warnings into patterns you can spot quickly.

None of this means buying bullion is unsafe. Millions of ounces change hands through legitimate dealers every year. The schemes below depend on you being contacted, rushed, and steered. If you choose the dealer, the product and the timing yourself, most of these scripts simply cannot reach you. Our safe online buying checklist covers the basics.

Red Flag 1: The Unsolicited, High-Pressure Pitch

The CFTC advisory lists a cluster of sales-pitch warning signs: claims that a news event guarantees big profits, salespeople who call you, advertising that drives you to a phone line, and requests for your personal details early in the conversation. The persuasion tactics follow a script:

  • Guaranteed or outsized returns. Phrases like "this purchase is certain to double" are a hallmark the CFTC calls out directly. Metal prices move in both directions; the FTC's testimony pointed to gold's sharp decline in 2013 as an example.
  • False urgency. "Only two left" or "the price goes up when the overseas market opens" exists to stop you from comparing prices.
  • Borrowed credibility. Senior-sounding titles, special credentials, or name-dropping other investors "who already got in."
  • A small favor first. A tiny initial purchase that sets up a much larger request later.

A legitimate dealer will happily let you hang up, compare, and order online days later at whatever the market price is then.

Red Flag 2: Financed or Leveraged Metal

One of the most damaging structures in both the CFTC and FTC materials is the financed purchase. You pay a fraction of the price upfront (the CFTC cites 15% to 25%), and the company arranges a "loan" for the rest. The FTC's testimony described interest on these loans and fees charged on the full purchase price, not just your deposit. If the metal's price falls, the firm may force a sale of your position to cover the loan, which can wipe out what you put in.

These deals are often paired with a promise that your metal is safely stored "in a bank" or a depository, sometimes overseas, that you never see. The CFTC specifically lists unclear identification of the lender and the physical location of the metal, and delivery to an overseas storage facility, as warning signs.

Stop sign: if you are told that precious metals transactions "aren't regulated by the CFTC or NFA," the CFTC treats that statement itself as a red flag. You can check whether a firm or individual is registered using the National Futures Association's BASIC database.

Red Flag 3: The Rare-Coin Switch

A common pattern starts with fear (inflation, a market crash, a looming crisis) and ends with the buyer holding coins sold at enormous markups. The salesperson steers you away from widely traded bullion, often by claiming it could be confiscated or reported, and toward "rare," "semi-numismatic," "limited," or "exclusive" coins whose value is hard to check.

The problem is not collectible coins themselves; it is the gap between what you pay and what any other dealer would pay you back. Before buying anything described as rare, ask two questions: what is the coin's precious metal content, and what would the seller pay to buy it back today? If either answer is evasive, walk away. Our premiums explainer shows how to translate any price into a cost per fine ounce so you can compare.

The same switch appears in retirement accounts. Be wary of anyone who urges you to move IRA or 401(k) savings into metals quickly, pushes a specific collectible coin, or promises that you can keep IRA metal at home. IRS rules on IRA-held metal are strict, and the tax consequences of getting them wrong can be significant.

Red Flag 4: "Government Agents" Who Want Your Gold Bars

A newer scheme does not sell you metal at all. It starts with an unexpected call, text, pop-up, or email claiming that your bank account or computer has been hacked, or that your identity is linked to a crime. The caller poses as a government agent or bank investigator and instructs you to "protect" your savings by withdrawing cash, buying gold bars, and handing them to a courier or delivering them somewhere.

The FTC's guidance is blunt: no one from the government will ever tell you to buy and deliver gold bars, move your money, or give cash to anyone. If you get this request, stop, hang up or stop replying, block the number, tell someone you trust, and report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Red Flag 5: Fake Dealer Websites and Marketplace Bait

Online, the risk is less about pressure and more about impersonation and too-good-to-be-true pricing:

  • Prices well below every major dealer for the same product.
  • Lookalike domain names or copied branding from a real dealer.
  • Payment only by wire to an individual, gift cards, peer-to-peer apps, or cryptocurrency sent to a personal wallet.
  • Wire instructions that "change" by email after you order.
  • No street address, no phone number, or a phone number that never connects.

Physical counterfeits are a separate problem, common on marketplaces and social media. Our guide on how to spot counterfeit gold and silver coins covers weight, dimension and magnet checks.

Red Flag Quick Reference

What you hear or seeWhy it mattersSafer move
"Guaranteed" profit or price doublingMetals can and do fallEnd the call
Pay 15–25% now, we finance the restLeverage, interest and forced liquidation riskBuy only what you pay for in full
Your metal is stored in a bank overseasYou cannot verify the metal existsUse a named, verifiable depository or take delivery
Bullion may be confiscated; buy these rare coins insteadClassic setup for huge markupsAsk for metal content and today's buyback price
Government agent says buy gold bars for safekeepingImpostor scam per the FTCHang up; report at ReportFraud.ftc.gov
Wire to a person or pay with gift cardsUntraceable and irreversiblePay only a vetted business account
"Precious metals aren't regulated"Flagged by the CFTC itselfCheck NFA BASIC; walk away

Prefer to choose your own dealer, on your own timeline? Start with dealers whose reputations you can check.

Compare Bullion Dealers →

If You Think You Have Been Targeted

  1. Stop sending money. Do not send a "final fee" to release your metal or your refund; recovery pitches are a known follow-on scam.
  2. Call your bank immediately if you sent a wire or ACH payment. Speed matters for any chance of a recall.
  3. Report it. Use ReportFraud.ftc.gov for consumer fraud and the CFTC's tip and complaint process at cftc.gov/complaint for commodity-related schemes. Your state attorney general's consumer protection office is another option.
  4. Keep everything: call logs, emails, texts, contracts, wire confirmations and shipping labels.

Bottom line

Legitimate bullion buying is boring: you pick a dealer, compare a delivered price, pay in full, and receive insured metal. Anything that adds urgency, leverage, mystery storage, "rare" upsells or a government badge is a script, and the regulators have already written it down.

Frequently Asked Questions

Ordinary cash purchases of physical bullion with prompt delivery are generally not handled like futures trades, but the CFTC has authority over fraud in commodity markets and over certain leveraged or financed retail metals transactions. Its advisory treats claims that metals deals are "not regulated" as a warning sign.
Not always, but the CFTC lists unsolicited calls from brokers or salespeople among its warning signs. The safest habit is to never buy from a cold call; look up dealers yourself and order on your own terms.
No. The FTC states that no one from the government will ever tell you to buy and deliver gold bars, move your money, or give cash to anyone. Treat that request as a scam and report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
Nothing in principle, but they are often sold at markups far above their metal value, and the price you can get back may be much lower. Ask for the metal content and a written buyback quote before buying any coin pitched as rare or exclusive.
The National Futures Association's BASIC database lets you search firms and individuals registered in the futures industry. A lack of registration is not proof of fraud for a simple bullion dealer, but anyone pitching financed or leveraged metal should be easy to find there.

This guide is for general information only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Product specifications, dealer policies and rules change; confirm current details with the dealer, the issuing mint or the relevant agency before you act.

Dealer comparison

Compare live bullion options before you buy

Dealer premiums, shipping thresholds and inventory change. Compare the final delivered price and product availability before placing an order.

Silver Gold Bull → Money Metals → Kitco → Bullion.com →

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no added cost to you. Dealer inclusion here is not a guarantee that any one dealer has the lowest price for your order.